Intersecting Citizenship Regimes: The Production of New Citizens in Brussels

Friday, July 10, 2015
H401 (28 rue des Saints-Pères)
Eva Swyngedouw , Sociology, University of Chicago
In this paper I research how new moral citizens are produced in an urban environment were two citizenship regimes intersect. I use a comparative approach to investigate citizen-making practices in newcomer migrant reception offices in the multi-institutional and bilingual city of Brussels. In Brussels, both the French-speaking community and the Flemish-speaking community organize their own welcoming initiatives, including citizenship classes for newcomers.

Building on participant observation in these reception offices, I argue that citizenship stretches beyond the economical and political sphere. Integration has a profoundly moral dimension to it. The reception offices particularly focus on teaching migrants the habitus of a ‘good’ citizen. However, good citizenship behavior is interpreted and explained to newcomers in a different way in practice. Immigrant newcomer’s conduct is thus conducted differently in one city.

What is at stake here is the very identity and sense of self of the two linguistic communities. I contend that their engagement in a continued struggle over the governance of migrants’ conduct is used as a tool to refine the boundaries of belonging between the two communities themselves. In an increasingly cosmopolitan city like Brussels, the promotion of Flemish-ness or a distinctive francophone civic identity becomes a peculiar anomaly that does not stroke with urban reality. This study’s findings not only shed light on the micro processes whereby new moral citizens are produced, but also encourage more research about the importance of sub-national forms of citizenship.

Paper
  • Creating autonomous individual citizens in a neoliberal age.pdf (236.4 kB)