Analysing the Support for Conditional and Non-Conditional Activation Policies in Western Europe: The Effect of Labour Market Risk, Socioeconomic Status and Ideology

Thursday, July 9, 2015
H401 (28 rue des Saints-Pères)
Flavia Fossati , Institute of Political Science, University of Zurich
In the last decades all over Europe governments introduced active labour market policies (ALMPs) to address typically post-industrial (long-term) unemployment rates. Whilst these reforms have been studied in detail (Clasen and Clegg 2011; Bonoli and Natali 2012), up to the present it has hardly been explored whether and why citizens endorse particular ALMPs.

In this article, I argue first that ALMP support does not follow the “traditional” generosity conflict patterns which are characteristic for passive welfare benefits. Rather, I maintain that the endorsement of particular ALMPs can be explained in terms of being pro or contra conditionality. Using a novel comparative survey on labour market attitudes I show that the higher the level of labour market vulnerability the more likely and individual is to support non-conditional ALMP (training/public job creation) as compared to conditional ones (sanctions).

Moreover, I show that ideological orientation interacts with labour market and social status. In more detail, I find that unemployed individuals with a left-libertarian ideology are more likely to reject conditional ALMPs as compared to left-leaning employed. Interestingly, the effect for this group is constant independently of their socioeconomic status. Instead, this is not the case for individuals adhering to the right political spectrum. In this group employed are more likely to favour conditionality as compared to unemployed, however, this effect becomes markedly stronger with increasing socioeconomic status. In sum, this article demonstrates that modelling interactions between vulnerability, socioeconomic status and ideological affiliation is pivotal to understand support patterns for conditional and non-conditional ALMPs.

Paper
  • Fossati_CES2015.pdf (329.7 kB)