168 Do Parties Make a Difference in Policy-Making? Rethinking the Party-Policy Link

Do political parties make a difference? Electoral competition, accountability and policy change
Thursday, July 9, 2015: 2:00 PM-3:45 PM
H202A (28 rue des Saints-Pères)
Party politics remain marginal in studies of the policymaking that tend either to ignore this variable, or to emphasize their marginality or their residual character. According to many authors, parties have become unable to implement the public policies for which they have been elected, so that policies do not differ a lot depending on the party in government. They are rather seen to reflect path dependence, the resources and expertise available, and interest groups’ demands. This leads many authors to argue that policies are (increasingly) made beyond parties.

This panel proposes to rethink the link between parties and policies: Do parties in office respect their electoral promises ? What amount of policy change can be directly attributed to party politics? At what stage of the policy process parties are more likely to impact public policy? Under what conditions is partisanship in policymaking most likely? How much are parties sanctioned (or rewarded) by voters when they fail (or succeed) to respect their engagements?

This panel will hence focus on dynamics of policy change, with a focus on accountability. The idea is to contribute to understanding partisanship in policymaking by gathering several strands of international research in the field of political parties and public policy.

Organizer:
Isabelle Guinaudeau
Chair:
Simon Persico
Discussant :
Simon Persico
Party Competition, the Transmission of Policy Agendas, and the Gap Between Electoral Priorities and Policy Outputs
Federico Russo, NOVA University of Lisbon; Enrico Borghetto, Nova University Lisbon; Marcello Carammia, University of Malta
Do parties matter for policymaking? Capacity, incentives and partisan agenda setting in France
Sylvain Brouard, Sciences Po Bordeaux; Caterina Froio, Université Paris 2 Panthéon-Assass; Emiliano Grossman, Sciences Po, CEE; Isabelle Guinaudeau, Sciences Po Grenoble, CNRS; Simon Persico, Sciences Po, CEE
Who’s in Control? Voters, Parties and Policy Sectors
Claire Dupuy, Sciences Po, CEE; Raul Magni-Berton, Sciences Po Grenoble