Not ‘Coming out’? Addressing Serbia’s Sexual Orientation Anti-Discrimination Implementation Gap

Wednesday, March 28, 2018
Streeterville East (InterContinental Chicago Magnificent Mile)
Dr. Koen Slootmaeckers , Department of International Politics, City, University of London, United Kingdom
In 2009, Serbia adopted its comprehensive anti-discrimination law as part of the country’s European integration and the EU’s visa-liberalisation process. The literatures on the Europeanisation of minority and lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) rights have clearly demonstrated that such externally imposed laws are often badly implemented. However, a comprehensive analysis of the implementation gap of the Serbian anti-discrimination law has not been conducted to date. This paper, addresses this gap through an in-depth analysis of barriers to the law’s implementation, focusing on its LGBT dimensions.

The Europeanisation literature has argued that the conditionality’s limited penetration as well as the lack of institutional capacity have led to an implementation gap. With the argument implying that stronger institutions will in time overcome the implementation gap. In other words, the literature seemingly operates under the assumption that institutional change (if done well) will eventually lead to social change. This paper challenges such assumption by drawing attention to the societal barriers to the anti-discrimination law’s implementation.

It is argued that the implementation gap cannot be reduced to a lack of political will and more general issues with the rule of law in Serbia, as the social conditions for good implementing have not been created. Not only is the general understanding of the concept of discrimination limited in Serbia, but more importantly, LGBT people’s fear of being ‘outed’ and of social isolation prevents them from using the law. In short, the paper makes the case for a societal analysis of limited Europeanisation.